Your NSW team for Game 3

KnightFan93 said:
Wow, really, I just forgot my favourite players nationality...
wtf???? Obviously i knew that, just because he plays for Fiji doesn't mean that NSW don't need him.
Click to expand...

So... er why say it? Why not say instead 'If only Uate was eligible for NSW, he would be great on the wing.'

Instead of not saying it, people being confused and then you wtfing over something that started with what you said.

Pretty silly.

jamesgould said:
Yes but it does mean he needs to stand down for two years until he can play for NSW, so far it's been 6 months.
Click to expand...

Yeh, dare say if he didn't play for Fiji he might have been the winger for NSW the other night. Imagine him running down the sideline scoring for the Blues.
 
knightsfan2010 said:
Yes. He should not be there.



There are plenty of better Fullbacks and more skillful Fullbacks than Jarrad Hayne.
Click to expand...

Quite possibly the craziest thing I have ever heard.

Like who? Kurt Gidley? Josh Dugan?

Hayne is a match winner and hey he might not have shown it for the first two games, he hasn't had a pack in front of him either.
 
1 gidley (c)
2 hayne
3 lyon
4 joel tompson
5 morris
6 bird
7 pearce
8 snowden
9 farah
10 douglas
11 hindmarsh
12 creagh
13 gallen

14 cross
15 lewis
16 tim grant
17 mason
 
Gidley... Hayne.

Difference in skill, even behind a pack going forward Gidley cant be a match winner.

Has he even scored a try in the 8 games he has played? Bit of a worry.
 
-AK- said:
Quite possibly the craziest thing I have ever heard.

Like who? Kurt Gidley? Josh Dugan?

Hayne is a match winner and hey he might not have shown it for the first two games, he hasn't had a pack in front of him either.
Click to expand...

Well, I can see where you are coming from there, however I'd rate Gidley over Hayne.

Hustler said:
This!

Maybe he shouldn't be playing fullback but noway we want him dropped he's probably the only attacking weapon we have. If you wana disagree with me I suggest you watch last couple of Origins.
Click to expand...

I have watched the last couple of Origins. Last night: Dropped the ball and just starred until the Maroons dived on it and last year: Running down the sideline with the scores close. Puts a foot on the sideline. I think I've seen enough to know that he makes stupid decisions at Origin level. I think he is good at club level but he can't cut it at Origin.
 
Gidley is a workhorse not a match winner, but seems he's not up to the task at origin level infact he's not even playing his actual game.
 
knightsfan2010 said:
Well, I can see where you are coming from there, however I'd rate Gidley over Hayne.



I have watched the last couple of Origins. Last night: Dropped the ball and just starred until the Maroons dived on it and last year: Running down the sideline with the scores close. Puts a foot on the sideline. I think I've seen enough to know that he makes stupid decisions at Origin level. I think he is good at club level but he can't cut it at Origin.
Click to expand...
You're joking right? I'm guessing you didn't watch Origin last year then?
 
knightsfan2010 said:
Well, I can see where you are coming from there, however I'd rate Gidley over Hayne.



I have watched the last couple of Origins. Last night: Dropped the ball and just starred until the Maroons dived on it and last year: Running down the sideline with the scores close. Puts a foot on the sideline. I think I've seen enough to know that he makes stupid decisions at Origin level. I think he is good at club level but he can't cut it at Origin.
Click to expand...

lol last night was one of his bad games I admit but there are heaps of others who shouldn't even be there. I'm not jumping on the Haynetrain but are you being serious about him stepping on the sideline? People still debate whether that should have been a try or not , what matters is he was NSW's best player last Origin and his debut was superb. I wouldn't judge him based on one series when he has proved himself at club level and representative level, a man cant be expected to step up every year when others around him falter.
 
Hustler said:
lol last night was one of his bad games I admit but there are heaps of others who shouldn't even be there. I'm not jumping on the Haynetrain but are you being serious about him stepping on the sideline? People still debate whether that should have been a try or not , what matters is he was NSW's best player last Origin and his debut was superb. I wouldn't judge him based on one series when he has proved himself at club level and representative level, a man cant be expected to step up every year when others around him falter.
Click to expand...

Why not? everyone is doing that to Gids constantly.
 
Pick a young side for the future....:think:

1- Josh Dugan
2- Aku Uate
3- Joel Thompson
4- Jamaal Idris
5- James McManus
6- Todd Carney
7- Mitchell Pearce
13- Chris Lawrence
12- Cory Paterson
11- Tom Learoyd-Lahrs
10- Luke Douglas
9- Kurt Gidley (c)
8- Kade Snowden

14- Matt Hilder
15- Michael Weyman
16- Aiden Tolman
17- Tim Grant

18- Sam McKendry
 
Matho said:
Pick a young side for the future....:think:

1- Josh Dugan
2- Aku Uate
3- Joel Thompson
4- Jamaal Idris
5- James McManus
6- Todd Carney
7- Mitchell Pearce
13- Chris Lawrence
12- Cory Paterson
11- Tom Learoyd-Lahrs
10- Luke Douglas
9- Kurt Gidley (c)
8- Kade Snowden

14- Matt Hilder
15- Michael Weyman
16- Aiden Tolman
17- Tim Grant

18- Sam McKendry
Click to expand...

Like the idea but some selections are just wack man. Hilder, Lawerance at lock?
 
You must log in or register to reply here.
Back
Top