SOO Game 1: NSW v QLD @ ANZ Stadium

Pick the margin for NSW v QLD

  • NSW by 13+

    Votes: 2 10.5%
  • NSW by 1-12

    Votes: 12 63.2%
  • QLD by 13+

    Votes: 1 5.3%
  • QLD by 1-12

    Votes: 4 21.1%

  • Total voters
    19
  • Poll closed .
Gids played well i thought he made a few mistakes but damn it was wet!!!
We need the liked of hindmarsh and Gallen back.
The thing QLD has over us and thurston pointed it out after the game the team is a unit the majority have been playing for the past 5 years.
Joey running the waters was a pretty good idea he would have been ripping into the boys bet it was hard for him not to run up in the line and call for the ball lol
 
Gids played well i thought he made a few mistakes but damn it was wet!!!
We need the liked of hindmarsh and Gallen back.
The thing QLD has over us and thurston pointed it out after the game the team is a unit the majority have been playing for the past 5 years.
Joey running the waters was a pretty good idea he would have been ripping into the boys bet it was hard for him not to run up in the line and call for the ball lol

ppl around me were suggesting they just give Joey & Langer jersey's and let them play.

everyone talking as though we were overrun is a bit premature, yes it will be hard to win in QLD, yes we should have won last night, but seriously how can you win when the ref seems to have a pre-determined idea of who is going to win? (yes i am blaming the ref because on atleast 2 occasions QLD should not have even had the ball when they scored)

Gids should start at 6 in every game (club & state) and Lyon should go back out to the centres, dumbest thing they did was move Tahu off Inglis in the second half should have used Cooper not coming back on as a chance to play Hayne at FB and Gids up in the halves.
 
I thought Gids hogged it a fair bit, centres seen no ball all game, it was all this running up the middle sh*t.

Kicking game was off, too. Typical NSW game.
 
I'm tired of this Hayne to fullback nonsense. Look at Darius Boyd, he plays better at fullback yet he managed to score and a comment was made last night by the commentary team that Boyd has played most of his career on the wing just like Hayne. It didn't matter who was fullback, our forwards (especially Perry) were soo slow and sluggish that the only go forward we got was from our backs. Weyman tried, but that was about it. We were caught out by the same lazy forwards at marker and that's what cost us other than the Hayne misreads.
 
outclassed...outsmarted...out played...:cry:...so very disappointing from NSW...sure the guys ran hard and hit hard but Qld attacked as a team and always seemed to have someone just a short offload away...we attacked like 13 individuals...when we did put a few passes together we looked quite good but they always had our measure and I think the scoreline flattered us...bugger it...
 
Nsw side game two

Unfortunately there's no point complaining about last night, everyone thought they would do alot better then they did but these are the changes id be implementing to give us half a chance against a side who welcomes back cam smith in game two.

NSW ORIGIN SIDE GAME 2

1. JARED HAYNE
(deserves his opportunity to prove he's the best, needs to link up with kimmorley and get lyon and morris into the game early)
2. BRETT MORRIS
(played on the wrong wing in game 1, he's a right winger not left)
3. JOSH MORRIS
(devastating attacker, in much better form then tahu)
4. JAMIE LYON
(the guys a centre not 5/8, in the best form of his career let him play where he has been most effective)
5. JOEL MONAGHAN
(everyones saying Jamal Idris, they must have been watching another game then me, sure he is great in attack but defensively there are some very very serious concerns.. lockyer and thurston would be licking their lips if he got picked because he simply rushes up in defence and panics everytime.. we need someone more solid in defence but at the same time can beat folau in the air and work in well with lyon)
6. KURT GIDLEY (c)
(done enough in the last 15 mins to warrant selection in front of barrett, he is in better form then trent and he's leadership will be crucial when they run out at suncorp)
7. BRETT KIMMORLEY
(needs someone to help take the pressure off, had way too much responsibility on his kicking game in the opener. Ennis needs to do more kicking from dummy half and gidley and even hayne from fullback need to do there bit aswell).
8. BEN CROSS
(plain and simple we were beaten up front, put cross in there.. alongside thaiday he is by far the hardest running forward in the game)
9. MICHAEL ENNIS
(putting hayne to fullback will help Ennis greatly in getting the boys going forward look for the combination of Ennis, Kimmorley and Hayne up the middle in game 2)
10. MICHAEL WEYMAN
(tough competitor but needs to lift because theres a forward by the name of luke douglas who is knocking down the door for an origin call up in game three if he doesnt perform)
11. NATHAN HINDMARSH
(re-cap from game one was that we need to get tougher in defence.. hmm anyone know a player who can make 50 tackles in an origin game simliar to a dallas johnson?? ... Nathan has to be there its a no brainer!)
12. PAUL GALLEN
(you dont understand how much i hate Gallen but along with the selection of Cross, they have to give Paul another shot because these two players hold to key to winning the game up front with their aggression)
13. ANTHONY WATMOUGH
(great player, the wet conditions didn't suit him in game 1 but give him a dry track in brisbane and this kids deadly)

INTERCHANGE

14. TRENT WATERHOUSE
(waterhouse and creagh were the best players in game 1, no question)
15. BEN CREAGH
(read above)
16. TOM LEAROYD LAHRS/LUKE DOUGLAS
(cant split them.. Lahrs has had a few chances now and has been fairly underwhelming so im leaning towards blooding Douglas but i can understand holding him back until game three)
17. LUKE LEWIS
(Lewis is the ideal utility he can cover any position and his footwork is causing everyone alot of problems)

Dropped:

Tahu- the guys solid in defence but he just hasn't shown that he can keep pace with Josh Morris in attack and we need more points.

Cooper- picked Lyon in front of him, Jamie's in career best form and cooper just isnt quite there.

Perry- got dominated everytime he touched the ball

White- same as perry except worse, his runs were terrible and he's out of form because he simply hasnt played enough games this year.

Idris- again no question he's a devastaing ball runner but origin is won on defence and he would have to be the worst defensive player in game one.
 
NSW just don't have the players to beat a great Queensland side at the moment! No point getting depressed about it, it's just how it is.
 
NSW just don't have the players to beat a great Queensland side at the moment! No point getting depressed about it, it's just how it is.

I really think we matched it with them. But again, like how many tries come off errors.

I thought the one on one strip with Gidley was stupid, but like... QLD just seem to pull these plays from no where.
 
I really think we matched it with them. But again, like how many tries come off errors.

I thought the one on one strip with Gidley was stupid, but like... QLD just seem to pull these plays from no where.

It didnt help that a couple of Queenslands tries came off sets where they shouldnt have had the ball, not that was an excuse.
 
i was there and i loved every bit of it except the result. gidley played really well IMO. i really loved the atmosphere. i was, however, really devastated with the score. a fair few s**t calls by the refs. kimmorley has to step up a bit if he wants to keep his place.
 
Loved this sign too:

803087-state-of-origin-i-nsw-v-qld.jpg
 
A lot of people calling for Gids to be dropped, and its sad to see they're blaming him for the loss

Haynes not going to do anything out on the wing if hes out of position...hes was terrible in defence and i really think for NSW to win hes gotta be moved to FB....and Gids > 5/8. I really see it as the only option.
 
Awesome sign, didn't see that one at the game. The only notable one I remember was 'We have a maths test tomorrow' :lol:

AK, what bay were you in?
 
A lot of people calling for Gids to be dropped, and its sad to see they're blaming him for the loss

Haynes not going to do anything out on the wing if hes out of position...hes was terrible in defence and i really think for NSW to win hes gotta be moved to FB....and Gids > 5/8. I really see it as the only option.

Whose calling for Gids to be dropped :confused:. He was NSW's best player
 
Im not talking about this forum. Im talking about the Blues fans...did you see that poll on the DT? 38% want him gone behind Matt Cooper at 50%.

Ahhhhh, i didnt see the DT, but then again i dont live in NSW haha...Wow blues fans are idiots. :think:, thats disappointing.
 
Back
Top