The whole thing is stupid. I absorb to much content, so I am 99% sure the whole rumour stared in bloke in a bar (love the beak btw). Guru predicted the roosters will target ponga once teddy retires. This was said a couple years ago after ponga resigned and he admitted it was baseless, just of vibe of being such a roosters thing to do. Literally later that week bunch of news articles came out about rumors/whispers bs and hasn't stopped since.
I have no doubt roosters are interested, but that is certainly how it started and I am sure politis is actually keen, but this is all it is.
Also the whole going to roosters to win a comp thing? I think roosters are the biggest under achievers in the comp. At most they have made finals 1 week deeper than us in the last five years with double the value in rosters. If ponga is serious about winning a comp with I don't think roosters are the team. I can see Robinson being pushed out in a year or two, he is being found out