England’s 2 main strike fast bowlers have had massive issues with fitness for years, the selectors obviously hoped they could get 1 or 2 good test matches out of them. Wood bowled very well in Perth even though he did not take any wickets but he lasted only 1 test. Archer’s state of mind as well as his fitness is questionable, does he have the mental stamina to consistently bowl aggressive spells against Australia? Carse was disappointing, Tongue may be much better.
England selected some batsmen who we would not be able to play well in Australian conditions, such as Pope. Duckett is struggling. Root is an exceptional batsman. Stokes will always fight hard and is a match winner on his day and Jacks looks promising. Brook will be liability until he stops playing reckless shots and getting himself dismissed cheaply. The selectors did not select enough replacement batsmen, Jacob Bethell’s first class experience is very limited.
Smith dropped a routine catch and is struggling with the bat, the selectors should have selected a full time backup keeper.
If the squad was large, fine the objective is to win the Ashes not to save money, some of the players who weren’t required for the early tests could have been lent out to the Lions to get match practice.
England’s preparation was woeful, one inter squad game of a flat batting track which was nothing like the wicket at Optus Stadium. A few training sessions under lights a no day/night match for a squad where most of the players haven’t played under lights hard to comprehend.
It looks as though the Bazball without brains strategy has been reined in, but it took 1 and a half test matches for the English management to realise it was not going to work. Unfortunately for them they are 2 test matches down and they have never come from 2 test matches down to win a series.
Archer may have fired up the Aussies and Cummins and Lyon will be itching to get at the English batsmen in Adelaide.
There should be a thorough clean out of the underperforming English players, management and selectors at the end of the series.
As a diehard Aussie cricket tragic, I’m finding it hard to believe how incompetent England have been in their preparation, selection and attitude for this series.