Wing Wants The NSW No.7
- Thread starter knight-no-7
- Start date
Bedsey_is_the_best
Adam MacDougall
The same Wing as you. I don't think he is bad, just not as good as everyone makes out. Thats my opinion I never said everyone had 2 agree
knight-no-7
Moderator
AussieKnight said:
haha
id laugh if he does end up with the NSW No7
jamesgould said:
Too be totally truthful James, in '02 when the Rorters won the comp he did play along side Fittler who pretty much ran the show and Wing played more of a dummyhalf roll than a true halfback. I would be very disappointed if the selectors go back to their "jerseys for the boys" mentality which has got NSW in the position its in currently.
NthKnight said:
Fittler did a lot, but Wing was no Perry. And Finch was unable to have as much success as he did.
In my opinion he has also been playing out of position since 2002, which hasn't helped him play his best football week to week, or in rep football.
mozza
Game on broheim
anyone but brett kimmorley will be good
i wouldnt say eing is overated he was one of the if not the main reason they made 3 grand finals in a row and he was really good at the end of last year
if mullen shows form he deserves to be halfback he played a bad game which was his first and he was only 20 yet kimmorley had played origin before is like 30 played just as bad and got another game that is ****
i wouldnt say eing is overated he was one of the if not the main reason they made 3 grand finals in a row and he was really good at the end of last year
if mullen shows form he deserves to be halfback he played a bad game which was his first and he was only 20 yet kimmorley had played origin before is like 30 played just as bad and got another game that is ****
knight-no-7
Moderator
It will be Kimmorley and Bird i bet. God i hate Kimmorley too. Hope Mullen can shine and put his hands up for the job.
Bedsey_is_the_best
Adam MacDougall
Kimmorley did an ok job at origin last year, despite the fact I don't like him. at the end of the day they should just go with the player in the best form, regardless of age of history or whatever. We need to win this series
Kimmorley is another decent option in my opinion. Very consistent, doesn't have the touches of brilliance he had a few years ago, but equally he won't lose you the match, either.
I think I'd have Kimmorley at halfback and Mullen at five eighth, myself. I think the selectors may go for Todd Carney though, and Bird at five eighth.
I think I'd have Kimmorley at halfback and Mullen at five eighth, myself. I think the selectors may go for Todd Carney though, and Bird at five eighth.
knight-no-7
Moderator
No Way Walsh, too inexperienced. They wouldnt blood someone like that when they have Kimmorley/ Other options.
Bedsey_is_the_best
Adam MacDougall
I wouldn't say kimmorley wouldn't lose us a game because he can and he has in the past. And no way luke walsh, apart from lack of experience he really isn't good enough anyway
That was three years ago though, I don't think he would do that now.
Bedsey_is_the_best
Adam MacDougall
um i dunno. I think he could, but basically I still think he is a good option, if he is playing in form
knight-no-7
Moderator
They'll go to him, if they cant find anyone, Only because he's experienced. I personally think he's hopeless ( sorry but i dont like him ).