1. Milton Thaiday
2. Brian Carney
3. Owen Craigie
4. George Carmont
5. The Rossdog
6. Sean Rudder
7. Leo Dynevor
13. Brodie Jones
12. Chris Houston
11. Zeb Taia
10. Matt Parsons
9. Bill Peden
8. Glenn Grief
14. Lord Gamble
15. Matt Hilder
16. Sione Mata'utia
17. Troy Fletcher
A "cult hero" to me is an unlikely hero, a player who's somewhat obscure and destined to be loved by that club's fanbase but forgotten by a lot of NRL fandom more broadly. There's a segment on NRL Boom Rookies called "Gee, what about this bloke?" where they talk about this kind of player, they refer to them as "blokes" or "guys". To me it's your unfashionable battler who has more good/memorable moments than you'd expect, your big oaf with a big personality, or your guy with all the talent in the world who for some reason could never put it together. That's a "cult hero", that's a guy, that's a dude.
Andrew Johns isn't a "cult hero". He's just a hero.
Bill Peden, hero to Knights fans, scored a double in a grand final, *but* never got within cooee of a rep jersey - that's a cult hero.