Newcastle Knights vs Penrith Panthers @ EAS Stadium

Buderus rated 50-50 to face Panthers
16/08/2007 8:06:27 PM
Mark Hughes
Sportal
Newcastle Knights coach Brian Smith has rated skipper Danny Buderus as only an even money chance to play in this Sunday's NRL match against the Penrith Panthers at Energy Australia Stadium.

Buderus has been sidelined for over a month with a chronic Achilles tendon problem and despite running well at training is still in doubt for the round 23 clash.

"We are hoping that Danny will get through but it us probably 50-50 at best," Smith said at Knights training on Thursday.

"He has done quite a bit of training in the last few weeks but is still limited in some contact issues. We will see how he goes again today and we will give him till Saturday to see how he is.

"We have Riley Brown on stand-by as well as Michael Young, with Michael the likely starter."

Smith's other injury concern was dynamic young winger James McManus, who found out this week he has a broken rib.

"James has had an x-ray that shows he has a fractured rib," said Smith.

"The specialist has told him he can play if he can stand the pain and I could have answered that for him because Jimmy has been playing with pain all year long. But I don't know if this one is going to get the better of him.

"I can't push him today for obvious reason – we are just going to see how he is going on Saturday morning and trust him, which is a most unusual thing to be doing with a 20-year-old, but Jimmy has proven himself over and over again this season to be able to play with pain and injury.

"He has been Mr Reliable and it means a lot to him to continue to play every minute of every game, which he has done this season so we will be looking at it favourably I would imagine."

Smith was tightlipped on any comments regarding Kirk Reynoldson's situation but indicated the club had weathered the storm and was looking forward to this Sunday's match-up against the Panthers.

"I think Kirk's situation has been reported fully as far as I am aware, I am just happy to deal with the team this weekend," said Smith.

"It was pretty obvious that we have had a couple of torrid weeks and this week we have had a bit of an easing in that.

"We got some of our best results out of the gym this morning which means that our guys are not only physically strong but mentally prepared.

"I think every team has got plenty to win and plenty to lose out of every game of footy, but it is generally the guys who can muster the pride in their own performance, no matter what the score, no matter what the venue.

"Every player who has that about them is a quality NRL player – I think we have plenty of those guys and I think we will be ready for whatever Penrith come with and perhaps a bit more."
 
I just heard on Newcastle radio that they were expecting him 2 play but he has aa fitness test 2morrow. Looks like nobody knows what is going and reporters are just saying what they want
 
He ruled in 03 and 04 ... a change of scene will help him. He can be a brilliant player.
 
It's the battle to end all battles

Greg Prichard
August 18, 2007

NEWCASTLE versus Penrith … Sure, it's not the biggest game of the round when it comes to positions on the competition table, but how would you like to finish last and get the wooden spoon?

It's got Penrith's name on it at the moment, but there would still be a way out for them over the last two rounds if they could beat the Knights at EnergyAustralia Stadium tomorrow. The Panthers would have been playing to get off the bottom of the table had they beaten North Queensland at home on Monday night, but you saw what happened there.

Leading by 10 points with five minutes to go, only to be reeled in and end up losing in golden point extra time … it was a lesson in why Penrith have failed this season. Poor decision-making and loss of intensity has cost them dearly.

Newcastle, running second-last, are four points clear of the Panthers, but here's the rub: the points differential of the Knights (-242) is the worst in the competition and more than twice as bad as Penrith's (-104).

Losing tomorrow would gift Penrith the spoon, but if they won then it would be game on in rounds 24 and 25.

Cronulla, St George Illawarra and Canberra could even be dragged back into the thick of the battle through a Penrith victory, depending on other results this weekend.

The Knights have gone through a horror period, on and off the field. They have lost five straight games and coach Brian Smith's player clean-out for next year has been under the spotlight. Player morale has been down off the field and commitment on it has slipped.

Even though Newcastle were playing a top team in Manly last round, it was obvious from the way they went about things that the Knights had let the situation get them down. Asked whether we should anticipate Newcastle lifting tomorrow - and, if so, how they proposed to do it - representative forward Steve Simpson was honest with his reply.

"You just have to put the blinkers on, try to shut everything else out and concentrate on the football," he said.

"I've tried not to read the newspapers this week and just focus on the game. It's been a tough month, and last week, in particular, was a really tough week. It was hard to focus and I think that showed.

"But we've made an attempt to put all of that behind us leading up to this game and concentrate on what we have to do and the focus has been a lot better. It has to be, because we need to win to avoid any chance of getting the wooden spoon. We can't make the finals, but avoiding the wooden spoon is certainly something worth fighting for.

"We got it two years ago and it's not a good feeling. We don't want to get it again."

Penrith may have lost a handle on the game in the dying stages against the Cowboys, but being competitive against them and winning the previous week against South Sydney is good form going into a game like this and the Knights are wary of them.

"Their recent form is a lot better than their position on the table suggests," Simpson said. "We're going to have to play at our best to beat them, because they've got some big, powerful blokes who run the ball well and [Craig] Gower is in form at halfback.

"I thought the effort was there from us early in the game against Manly, but things got away from us as the game wore on.

"Our defence has to be a lot better and our execution must improve, as well. We need to play a bit smarter and not waste our opportunities."

From: http://www.leaguehq.com.au/news/news/its-the-battle-to-end-all-battles/2007/08/17/1186857781422.html

Knights v Panthers

August 17, 2007

Sunday 3.00pm, EnergyAustralia Stadium

KNIGHTS: Kurt Gidley, James McManus, Brad Tighe, George Carmont, Cooper Vuna, Chris Bailey, Luke Walsh, Jesse Royal, Danny Buderus (capt), Steve Simpson, Zeb Taia, Daniel Abraham, Reegan Tanner. Interchange: Michael Young, Cory Paterson, Mitchell Sargent, Adam Woolnough.

PANTHERS: Jarrod Sammut, Mark O'Halloran, Michael Jennings, Maurice Blair, Michael Gordon, Luke Lewis, Craig Gower (capt), Joel Clinton, Luke Priddis, Bryan Norrie, Frank Pritchard, Trent Waterhouse, Nathan Smith. Interchange: Matthew Bell, Brendan Worth, Frank Puletua, Paul Aiton, Peter Wallace (one to be omitted).

Prichard's verdict: The Knights are struggling on the field and morale is down because of the player clean-out. Newcastle have won four of their past six clashes with the Panthers, riding on the back of Andrew Johns in most of those games. Penrith's recent form is competitive and they had the Cowboys beaten last round before clocking off too early.

STATISTICS
Head to head: Knights 15, Panthers 10, drawn 3.
At EnergyAustralia Stadium: Knights 6, Panthers 6.
Last week: Sea Eagles 50 bt Knights 16, Cowboys 30 bt Panthers 26.
Referee: Jason Robinson
TV: Channel Nine, 4.00pm

From: http://www.leaguehq.com.au/news/lhqmatchpreview/knights-v-panthers/2007/08/16/1186857685208.html
 
Knights, Penrith battle to avoid spoon
August 18, 2007 - 2:34PM

Two clubs in turmoil for events off the field, Penrith and Newcastle, will on Sunday share a common goal on the pitch as they battle to avoid the wooden spoon at all costs.

Mired at the bottom of the NRL ladder, Sunday's contest at EnergyAustralia Stadium could well determine which side ends up with the game's most unwanted prize.

The Panthers are currently last on 14 points with three rounds remaining while the Knights aren't too far ahead on 18.

Newcastle coach Brian Smith preferred the 'glass half full' approach when asked to how he hoped the season would finish for his side, the wooden spoon not even rating a mention.

"There's an opportunity for us this weekend, it's possible that we can jump three places with a win, and if we win another couple of games before the end of the season, we can finish mid-table," Smith said.

"I think everybody would agree if we can finish just outside the eight this year.

"It's not what we wanted, but given what we've had to handle with Andrew (Johns') retirement and the injuries we've had and all the young guys we've had to bring in throughout the course of the season, personally I think it's not a bad effort."

The Panthers still look odds on to finish bottom for the second time in seven years, their last-gasp loss to North Queensland on Monday night compounded by more off-field controversy through the week.

Prop Joel Clinton was on Friday suspended and three other players - departing halfback Craig Gower, former Test lock Trent Waterhouse and rookie Brendan Worth - fined after breaking team rules by drinking on their day off when they took part in a sponsor-organised charity golf day in Bundaberg on Wednesday.

It's hardly the sort of preparation coach Matthew Elliott would have been hoping for as he looks to engineer just his side's third win in its last 11 games, with dumped co-captain Tony Puletua likely to earn a reprieve to replace Clinton.

Up the F3 freeway, the Knights know victory on Sunday will ensure they don't end up with the wooden spoon for the second time in three seasons, but a loss could leave them in a precarious position thanks to their diabolical points differential of minus 242.

Newcastle themselves have been no strangers to controversy in recent times, the uncertainty surrounding backrower Kirk Reynoldson's future with the club the climax of a tough few weeks for the club which is still struggling to find its feet following the early season retirement of club great Andrew Johns.

Coach Smith, who has come under criticism from players and fans for his cleanout of the club's playing roster, was confident his players would be in a better frame of mind following their below par showing in going down 50-16 to Manly last weekend.

"Some of it is that it's passed, the tide has turned and some of it's also that our senior boys are starting to rally around and lift everybody else," Smith said

"We all feel pain when our club's hurting and wen we're making headlines for the wrong reasons, but I feel this week we've had a bit of an easing of all that and the players are in a better frame of mind."

There was more pain for the Knights on Saturday when skipper Danny Buderus was forced to abort his comeback due to ongoing knee soreness, while winger James McManus remains in doubt with a rib complaint.© 2007 AAP
 
were did u here this? i'm in total denial and am refusing 2 believe it untill it is confirmed, especially since all the crap that has been said all week. [-(
 
Raiders won last night, so todays game is even more important, if Knights lose, the spoon is heading to the hunter valley.
 
Not 4 sure, the panthers will still be 2 points behind us if they win today. But If we can't beat the panthers I doubt we will beat the cowboys or the tigers.
 
Back
Top