2011 City vs Country Origin Thread

(Purely backs-wise)

My guess at the test side would be:
1. Slater
2. B.Morris
3. Lyon
4. Inglis
5. Boyd
6. Lockey
7. Thurston
14. Cronk

Then
City:
1. Hayne
2. Minichiello
3. Gasnier
4. Champion
5. Jennings
(plus Hopoate, Wolfman, Turner, Reddy, Ayshford, Coote, Pomeroy, Merritt, T.Williams either close or likely to miss it due to injury)
6. K.Keating
7. Pearce
14. Hodgkinson

Country:
1. Gidley
2. Uate
3. Ferguson
4. Idris
5. Gordon
(plus Burt, Dugan, J.Thompson, Robertson, Croker, J.Morris, Stewart, Quinn)
..with Tahu very deliberately left out...doesn't deserve rep recognition ever again.
6. Carney
7. Mullen
14. Soward
 
Just a question if Uate is eligible for NSW and Country does that mean he is eligible for Australia?
 
(Purely backs-wise)

My guess at the test side would be:
1. Slater
2. B.Morris
3. Lyon
4. Inglis
5. Boyd
6. Lockey
7. Thurston
14. Cronk

Then
City:
1. Hayne
2. Minichiello
3. Gasnier
4. Champion
5. Jennings
(plus Hopoate, Wolfman, Turner, Reddy, Ayshford, Coote, Pomeroy, Merritt, T.Williams either close or likely to miss it due to injury)
6. K.Keating
7. Pearce
14. Hodgkinson

Country:
1. Gidley
2. Uate
3. Ferguson
4. Idris
5. Gordon
(plus Burt, Dugan, J.Thompson, Robertson, Croker, J.Morris, Stewart, Quinn)
..with Tahu very deliberately left out...doesn't deserve rep recognition ever again.
6. Carney
7. Mullen
14. Soward

Gidley will be playing in the ANZAC match.

Just a question if Uate is eligible for NSW and Country does that mean he is eligible for Australia?

Yep.
 
Test side because I'm bored!

1. Billy Slater
2. Brett Morris
3. Mark Gasnier/Jamie Lyon
4. Greg Inglis
5. Darius Boyd
6. Darren Lockyer
7. Johnathan Thurston
8. Matt Scott
9. Cameron Smith
10. Petero Civoniceva
11. Sam Thaiday
12. Nate Myles
13. Paul Gallen

14. Kurt Gidley
15. Greg Bird
16. Ben Hannant
17. Anthony Watmough
 
Dragons centre Matt Cooper offered chance to play for Country

636863-matt-cooper.jpg


THE CRL has offered an olive branch to in-form Dragons centre Matt Cooper and will allow him to play for Country against City if he reverses his decision to quit representative football.

Cooper has snubbed the CRL five times before, claiming he was injured and could not play.
But his form for the Dragons has been so irresistible that he will be welcomed back with open arms.
Cooper has maintained all season he is not interested in playing representative football at any level.
He and teammate Ben Hornby sent requests to the NSWRL two weeks ago asking to be excluded from all representative sides.

"It's a shame because he's playing some excellent football," CRL chief executive Terry Quinn said.
"I don't think we'd hesitate to name him. We'd be prepared to risk going through it all again. Risk him pulling out again.

"We've got a lot of talent in that spot, but of course we wouldn't say no."
Cooper pulled out of the Country side last year but played two Origin games for NSW.
CRL chairman Jack Colley had called on Cooper to be barred from Origin and vowed the centre would "never play for Country again".
Country have plenty of firepower to cover Cooper's absence. Jamal Idris, Jamie Lyon and Josh Morris are all strong centres who are available for selection.
Jamie Soward and Jarrod Mullen are the likely halves pairing for Country in the match against City in Albury on May 6.

DailyTelegraph
 
Paul Crawley says Jarryd Hayne should face off against Jamie Soward for Origin five-eighth spot

194257-hayne-and-soward.jpg

Source: The Daily Telegraph

ANY dog-eared quote book will tell you fortune favours the brave. Or winning isn't everything, it's the only thing. Or nothing great comes easy.


You've heard them all.

If you do what you've always done, you'll get what you've always got.

Let's think about that one when we think about NSW playing Queensland this year. When we think about five series loses in a row - and the same old names being thrown up for the same old positions, and how this year is going to be different. Maybe it's time for NSW to take the tip.

On Sunday selectors will name the teams for the City-Country game in Albury on May 6, and once again we're being fed the same names as candidates for what is the greatest problem area for the Blues - five-eighth.

While Jamie Soward is a certainty to wear the Country No. 6 jumper, the City boys have only Braith Anasta and John Sutton being mentioned as possibilities.

Are they the answer to NSW's problems?

Remember, if you do what you've always done ... it's time for the Blues to be bold.

Jarryd Hayne should wear the City No. 6 jumper. Make City-Country a fair dinkum Origin trial.

Hayne is our best option at fullback - but he could be an even bigger danger if we moved him to five-eighth.

Privately, some of the smartest minds in the game believe Hayne would be a sensation at No. 6 but until now no one has been brave enough to take the gamble.
It's time. Let's do it next Friday night. Why not play Hayne at five-eighth in a winner-takes-all shootout with Soward?

There is no way possible NSW will ever go back to Anasta for Origin and - on form - Sutton is as much chance of breaking into the Blues this year as Todd Carney. So to play either for City next Friday would waste everyone's time. We must consider Hayne.

When he went on that amazing run back in 2009, when the Eels made the grand final and Hayne was the best footballer on the planet, he did his greatest damage at first or second receiver. Think about it.

Hayne has every quality to be a successful playmaker. Big, powerful, fast. A monster kick and a wonderful pass. Think about it.
Nearly every try he scores is more a five-eighth's try than a fullback's. Think about it. Against the Bulldogs, before he planted a head-butt on Corey Payne, Hayne was killing Canterbury when he had the ball in his hands on the short side. Like Lockyer does.

Think about it. He scored two down the left and had Canterbury on the ropes until he blew his temper.Think about it. Jarryd Hayne was born to be a five-eighth but unfortunately for us somebody saw his talent for fullback first.

When Wayne Bennett first decided to move Lockyer from fullback to five-eighth everyone thought he was mad.
At some point this week Fittler and Stuart should sit down to discuss every option available to NSW and this option could just make sense.
On form, Soward has the inside running and deserves to be favourite.
But is it any less a gamble than Hayne? Let's make it a contest.

The other benefit is it opens the door to get both Hayne and Josh Dugan into the NSW side. We can't afford to leave either out. Dugan made his comeback from that calf injury for the Raiders last Sunday and was dangerous every time he touched the ball.
All he did wrong was argue with the refs which is something he must get out of his game to play Origin.
But he did set up both the Raiders tries and he almost set up the match-winner until poor Alan Tongue dropped the ball cold with the line open.
Of course, there is a strong chance Hayne will be picked on the wing for Australia which would kill off this argument before it gets hot.
But if Test selectors go for Brett Morris and Akuila Uate as Kangaroo wingers and leave Hayne for City then this option could evolve from fiction to fact by the end of this week. We can only hope.
Any dog-eared quote book will tell you fortune favours the brave. And that if you do what you've always done, you'll get what you've always got. Queensland has won the past five in a row - it's time to gamble.

http://www.dailytelegraph.com.au/sp...five-eighth-spot/story-e6frexnr-1226045219579
 
I don't even think Sutton has got a try assist this year, no way he should be there for City. I'd go with Anasta at 6 for City, he and Pearce are the halves for club level.
 
It is just an idea article. No guarantees he'll actually be selected there. It is an interesting idea but i can't see it being the answer for NSW.
 
Ricky Stuart gets hands-on with City-Country

NSW coach Ricky Stuart is taking a hands-on approach with City-Country selections to ensure all his Origin queries are answered.
Stuart said he had been in regular contact with City coach Brad Fittler and Country counterpart Laurie Daley, with teams for the annual clash to be named tomorrow.

While the City-Country clash in Albury next Friday has been criticised for its lack of relevance, Stuart said the fact there were so many Blues jumpers still up for grabs made it a genuine selection trial.

And it's a trial Stuart will take a keen interest in - because he will play a role in the selection of both sides.

"The communication with Laurie and Brad has been very productive and looking towards giving everyone in contention an opportunity to take that next step," Stuart said. "It's another level up from NRL - it's always an interest to see how individuals handle it."


Stuart claimed that only two players - likely skipper Paul Gallen and utility Kurt Gidley - were guaranteed selections for Origin I on May 25.

That will leave plenty to play for at Lavington Sports Ground next Friday, with five-eighth, hooker, the front-row, one wing and one centre spot in particular being wide open.

Gallen and Gidley will both miss the City-Country match due to likely Test call-ups for the Australia-New Zealand clash on the same night, with fellow New South Welshmen Tom Learoyd-Lahrs, Jarryd Hayne, Brett Morris, Greg Bird and Ben Creagh also in contention for what will be a Queensland-dominated Kangaroos line-up.

That group, along with Mark Gasnier and Michael Weyman, appear to be pencilled in to the NSW 17 for the Origin opener, Stuart admitting there was still plenty of time for the best-laid plans to come unstuck.

"I learnt a long time ago with rep teams that you can't pick them too far out," he said. "You never get to take that team on to the field because of injury and suspension."

Of most interest is who will wear the No. 6 jumper, with St George Illawarra pivot Jamie Soward, who is set to be teamed with Jarrod Mullen in the halves for Country, firming for a call-up.

LINK
 
What the DT thinks:

http://www.dailytelegraph.com.au/sp...tner-corey-payne/story-e6frexnr-1226047509617

City:
- Jarryd Hayne to play fullback & left out of the test side
- Corey Payne to be considered
- William Hopoate to play on the wing
- Mark Gasnier to return to rep footy
- Michael Jennings likely to play despite poor form
- Kris Keating & Wade Graham fighting over the five-eighth spot
- Mitchell Pearce guaranteed to be halfback
- Simon Dwyer a certain starter
- Experienced campaigners Robbie Farah, Jason King, Keith Galloway, Anthony Watmough & Mark Minichiello expected to provide leadership & direction
- Tim Grant on the bench
- Joesph Leilua considered as a bench utility

Country:
- Jamie Lyon to not be considered
- Blake Ferguson & Josh Morris fighting over Lyon's vacant centre spot if Jamal Idris is named on the test bench
- Glenn Stewart likely to be captain, joined in the backrow by Greg Bird & Beau Scott
 
City vs Country

the more I think about it, I keep seeing benefits of having it every second year. Atm it just feels to me. Oaky its back on what ever, its every year. but if they made it every second year I feel players would really rip in. use it to choose the squad for the next 2 years and it would make it more important. WHAT DO YOU THINK!!!:think:
 
its a tradition and its like state of origin for some of the players that arent good enough for state of origin so i think its a great tradition that should actually become like series not just one game
 
if players are going in with a worry of injury its not good. i think it would bring a bit more stability in the NSW side but i also agree its good to give those sort of players a rep game
 
It's a great idea, and I love watching it, but I don't like the whole deciding origin team. Queensland don't have this, and they choose the same team every year and win.
 
Back
Top