Senegal desperately unlucky with that penalty call i thought. Defender clearly had better position then the attacker and was swinging at the ball to clear it. If anything, I thought it was an attacker foul on defender.
50/50, i think it should be refs live decision and I think this is the problem with VAR (which has had a few improvements this tournament).
I don't think that’s an “OBVIOUS” error. Ref saw it and deemed it did not warrant a penalty. Likewise, if the referee calls a penalty, I don’t think you can overturn it.
There’s been a few very “soft” penalties awarded or goals overturned (Germany) for minimal contact. When it goes to VAR it’s VERY black and white. Is there contact. Yes. Penalty. Or in Germany’s case, minimal contact the keeper makes the most of - no goal.
Again we come back to consistency. Metcalfe was clipped from behind making a run into the box. Was it accidental - probably. But if you look at it objectively like VAR has done here - there’s contact, and in Metcalfe case denies an opportunity. I think that was a clearer penalty than this one - especially if we are overturning decisions.
Im fine with them not being given/overturned, or them all being given/overturned. But questions arise when there’s a discrepancy.
Edit to add that I think the offside technology/decision making on show has been excellent. Quick decisions. Accurate. Offside is objective - so I’m all for technology in this instance. Same with the corners being overturned - it’s often clear and objective. But penalties, fouls etc are mostly subjective decisions.