Round 5: Newcastle Knights vs Melbourne Storm

What is your prediction for this game ??

  • Knights 13+

    Votes: 5 33.3%
  • Knights 1-12

    Votes: 7 46.7%
  • Draw

    Votes: 0 0.0%
  • Storm 1-12

    Votes: 3 20.0%
  • Storm 13+

    Votes: 0 0.0%

  • Total voters
    15
  • Poll closed .
Cummins had a shocker but errors cost us

Not the result we wanted but still had a great start to the season, Bring on the Broncos next week !!
 
The ref has taken a lot away from the game today. Klemmer got ran into if it benefited the storm it would have been a penalty knights. Very poor call. I also thought vunivalu slipped into edrick's hips and wasn't hit high.

It would have been a nail biting finish.
 
I don't usually say this but the xxxxxxx refs are cheats … It didn't cost us the game our first half did but they made sure we didn't have a chance to win it .
 
The ref has taken a lot away from the game today. Klemmer got ran into if it benefited the storm it would have been a penalty knights. Very poor call. I also thought vunivalu slipped into edrick's hips and wasn't hit high.

It would have been a nail biting finish.

Its a unlucky penalty but it’s a penalty every day of the week. Always has been ruled that way whether the attacker slips or not.
 
Ref didn't cost us the game, but certainly ruined what would of been a good last 10 minutes.
Couple of bombed attempts in the second half, but still a great 40 minutes. Too bad we gifted them an 18 point headstart.
 
Our first half lost us the game. Pretty good effort from referee Smith in the 2nd half. We won all our games on ruck speed and playing footy. None of which we could do tonight.
 
The ref has taken a lot away from the game today. Klemmer got ran into if it benefited the storm it would have been a penalty knights. Very poor call. I also thought vunivalu slipped into edrick's hips and wasn't hit high.

It would have been a nail biting finish.

Storm player not being binned before half time, Lee Penalty, and Klemmer penalty were all LOL penalties from a weak ref, we had storm on the rack until he got them back into it.
 
Its a unlucky penalty but it’s a penalty every day of the week. Always has been ruled that way whether the attacker slips or not.

I havn't seen a replay but from what I saw edrick's upper body (i.e. arms) contacted his chest and then he sort of slid into his hips. The Klemmer one was horrible.
 
Back
Top