Who will Bennett axe, retain & recruit for 2013?

Red&Blue said:
We need to build a stronger pack Tony Willams, Sika Manu, Shannon Boyd, Mitchell Garbutt, Russle packer and Justin Poore are all off contract get them. And Get Joey on contract its a discrace hes coaching other teams and our halves are some of the worst in the NRL! Move Mckinnon to centre and Move Junior Sau to the forwards or march him!
Click to expand...
I would love tony Williams to play for the knights he will fit in perfectly!

---------- Post added at 09:19 PM ---------- Previous post was at 09:12 PM ----------

I know they look lost without gids , just like when Andrew johns wasn't playing ! Come to think of it ever since johns left the knights have not been playing like before!
 
the players i would get rid of would be
Matt Ballin/ Robbie Farah prefer farah for buderus assuming he retires
Costigan for David Stagg
junior Sau for Ben Smith
tahu for James Segeyaro
Sam Anderson to free up cap
Joel Edwards to free up cap
Richie Fa’aoso for Russell Packer
Siuatonga Likiliki to free up cap
Kyle O’Donnell to free up cap
Robbie Rochow to free up cap
Evarn Tuimavave to free up cap
Mark Wade to free up capzeb taia forLiam Fulton
Brett Stewart for gidley if he retire due to shoulder
Cuthbertson to free up cap
Roberts to free up cap
Adams to free up cap
Hilder to free up cap
 
Last edited:
John said:
the players i would get rid of would be
Matt Ballin/ Robbie Farah prefer farah for buderus assuming he retires
Costigan for David Stagg
junior Sau for Ben Smith
tahu for James Segeyaro
Sam Anderson to free up cap
Joel Edwards to free up cap
Richie Fa’aoso for Russell Packer
Siuatonga Likiliki to free up cap
Kyle O’Donnell to free up cap
Robbie Rochow to free up cap
Evarn Tuimavave for Fuifui Moimoi
Mark Wade
zeb taia forLiam Fulton
Brett Stewart for gidley if he retire due to shoulder
Cuthbertson for Ben Pomeroy
Roberts to free up cap
Adams to free up cap
Hilder for Ray Thompson
Click to expand...


I have seen some out of control posts on this thread, but this is by far the dumbest.
 
John said:
the players i would get rid of would be
Matt Ballin/ Robbie Farah prefer farah for buderus assuming he retires
Costigan for David Stagg
junior Sau for Ben Smith
tahu for James Segeyaro
Sam Anderson to free up cap
Joel Edwards to free up cap
Richie Fa’aoso for Russell Packer
Siuatonga Likiliki to free up cap
Kyle O’Donnell to free up cap
Robbie Rochow to free up cap
Evarn Tuimavave to free up cap
Mark Wade to free up capzeb taia forLiam Fulton
Brett Stewart for gidley if he retire due to shoulder
Cuthbertson to free up cap
Roberts to free up cap
Adams to free up cap
Hilder to free up cap
Click to expand...
You can't be serious right?
 
what im trying to say is that the knight have bought to many has beens (tahu, buderus ect) and crappy players (costigan, cuthberson ect)also players with potential and play in form that go out form once at knight(snowden, boyd ect), they will need a big change around brian smith style
 
John said:
what im trying to say is that the knight have bought to many has beens (tahu, buderus ect) and crappy players (costigan, cuthberson ect)also players with potential and play in form that go out form once at knight(snowden, boyd ect), they will need a big change around brian smith style
Click to expand...

Not as bad as Smith

Hilder
Costigan ( would stay under bennett though
Faaoso
Tuimavave

We sign quality players to replace the three . With size and mongrel,wouldn't really impact on the CORE of the team much
 
Dude all i said is Brett Stewart for gidley if he retire due to shoulder,Robbie Farah if buderus , retires
Costigan for David Stagg, junior Sau for Ben Smith, tahu for James Segeyaro, Richie Fa’aoso for Russell Packer, zeb taia forLiam Fulton and get rid of the rest of the **** players is that too much to ask?, we have tinkler, any way the cap would be freed up with all the **** players gone.
 
John said:
Dude all i said is Brett Stewart for gidley if he retire due to shoulder,Robbie Farah if buderus , retires
Costigan for David Stagg, junior Sau for Ben Smith, tahu for James Segeyaro, Richie Fa’aoso for Russell Packer, zeb taia forLiam Fulton and get rid of the rest of the **** players is that too much to ask?, we have tinkler, any way the cap would be freed up with all the **** players gone.
Click to expand...


HAHA :p

Simply concentrate on replacing the players I said with better ones

DOH!

 
John said:
the players i would get rid of would be
Matt Ballin/ Robbie Farah prefer farah for buderus assuming he retires
Costigan for David Stagg
junior Sau for Ben Smith
tahu for James Segeyaro
Sam Anderson to free up cap
Joel Edwards to free up cap
Richie Fa’aoso for Russell Packer
Siuatonga Likiliki to free up cap
Kyle O’Donnell to free up cap
Robbie Rochow to free up cap
Evarn Tuimavave to free up cap
Mark Wade to free up capzeb taia forLiam Fulton
Brett Stewart for gidley if he retire due to shoulder
Cuthbertson to free up cap
Roberts to free up cap
Adams to free up cap
Hilder to free up cap
Click to expand...

May as well fill up our NSW cup team with local bums then...
 
Knights should sign up Brett Finch from Wigan Warriors if they beat Souths to sign him up, He is an experienced 5/8 and can Mentor Mullen and not to mention he was the Newcastle Knights ball boy back in the Early 90's!!!!
 
John said:
the players i would get rid of would be
Matt Ballin/ Robbie Farah prefer farah for buderus assuming he retires
Costigan for David Stagg
junior Sau for Ben Smith
tahu for James Segeyaro
Sam Anderson to free up cap
Joel Edwards to free up cap
Richie Fa’aoso for Russell Packer
Siuatonga Likiliki to free up cap
Kyle O’Donnell to free up cap
Robbie Rochow to free up cap
Evarn Tuimavave to free up cap
Mark Wade to free up capzeb taia forLiam Fulton
Brett Stewart for gidley if he retire due to shoulder
Cuthbertson to free up cap
Roberts to free up cap
Adams to free up cap
Hilder to free up cap
Click to expand...

You can't be serious up in 'ere?!
 
relicorange94 said:
Knights should sign up Brett Finch from Wigan Warriors if they beat Souths to sign him up, He is an experienced 5/8 and can Mentor Mullen and not to mention he was the Newcastle Knights ball boy back in the Early 90's!!!!
Click to expand...

The time has well and truly passed where Mullen needs a mentor. It should be him leading the way. No excuses or talk just aim up. Re Finch at least he would bring some competitive spirit which is sadly lacking at the moment.
 
John said:
what im trying to say is that the knight have bought to many has beens (tahu, buderus ect)
Click to expand...

I like how you're calling Bedsy a 'has been' but yet he's your favourite player and also not to mention a Knights legend? Strange.. Please, don't be our coach after Bennett?! :fist:
 
Apparently we have resigned will smith for a further two seasons according to the twitter feed on the rugby league live app
 
Last edited:
After watching the Cowboys v Tigers highlights, i'm wondering when Tamou comes off-contract lol. He's been great this year. I didn't even rate him a year ago, must have been the lack of exposure up in NQLD.
 
You must log in or register to reply here.
Back
Top