Nathan Brown discussion

relicorange94 said:
Nathan Brown in my opinion is simply not the right choice, the only reason why he was successful in the Super League was when he was handed the St Helens squad after Roycie Simmons was thrown under a bus in 2012.
Click to expand...

Did a pretty good job with Huddersfield with a team that was barely able to complete 2yrs before.
 
Defender1 said:
Brown isn't the problem. We have too many Reserve graders calling themselves 1st graders.
Click to expand...

Why isn't brown developing reserve graders into first graders?

Everyone told me sione and the twins are going to be playing origin. Now they're reserve graders. Hard to keep up.
 
slotmachine said:
Why isn't brown developing reserve graders into first graders?

Everyone told me sione and the twins are going to be playing origin. Now they're reserve graders. Hard to keep up.
Click to expand...

For a guy that seemed to have common sense, you've fallen behind.

I think its mostly trolling cause what else can u do atm follwing this mess lol, though ur becoming a front runner with lord for banker of the year
 
Seems to me the argument is brown just needs to keep buying more players? It's certainly not on him to make them better.

In that case just make mooney the coach
 
Brown is the coach and will remain that way for a bit yet , we have a team it mightn’t be much but it’s ours, what Brownie needs to do his concentrate on developing a new attitude by getting them to play to the best of their ability , not give up and play for each other .

I have a stress headache from the recent Sharks game which wouldn’t hurt half as bad if i thought they were putting in for each other.
 
Damo Levy said:
Sorry but you will have to wait till he has his team.
Click to expand...

****ing lol this is year 3 sunshine. he bought three quarters of the players on the field today. this is his team, and he's taking it backwards quickly.

furthermore NSW Cup is a dumpster fire and we have absolutely no depth despite giving supposed coach brown licence to burn the place down and start again. he says the same team runs out again next week in the presser. that'll do me.

what on earth these brown apologists see I'll never know. He's a fantastic PR man but have seen zero on the field
 
slotmachine said:
****ing lol this is year 3 sunshine. he bought three quarters of the players on the field today. this is his team, and he's taking it backwards quickly.

furthermore NSW Cup is a dumpster fire and we have absolutely no depth despite giving supposed coach brown licence to burn the place down and start again. he says the same team runs out again next week in the presser. that'll do me.

what on earth these brown apologists see I'll never know. He's a fantastic PR man but have seen zero on the field
Click to expand...

Just because he bought them doesn’t mean they were his first choice players.

Lillyman? Heighington? Most players he has bought are stopgaps.

Over the past few years I have heard commentators make predictions of between 5-9 years for our rebuild.
Why are you expecting it to be quicker?

I haven’t seen anything to make me think Brown is a good coach but I won’t judge him until he has decent players.
 
Ivan Cleary turned the Tigers around in 12 months. I see them play and think they actually have a coach at the helm.

I watch us and think a drunk bloke in row ZZ is giving the half time talk.

Brown is never going to get all the players he wants. we're not the broncos.
 
slotmachine said:
Ivan Cleary turned the Tigers around in 12 months. I see them play and think they actually have a coach at the helm.

I watch us and think a drunk bloke in row ZZ is giving the half time talk.

Brown is never going to get all the players he wants. we're not the broncos.
Click to expand...

That’s comparing apples and oranges. Their problems were different and roster wasn’t as bad as ours.

Also they are sliding like us too.
 
Like it or not there is not much point discussing Brownies future. Fortunately for the factually incorrect haters here if he has a bad season in 2019 and the Wests aren't happy they can sack him and dust their hands of him. And who knows if Pearce gets injure again maybe even sooner!
 
I am a big Brown fan I think he has done a lot for this club and have defended him on here numerous times before but after the last month I think you would be naive to not think Wests are looking at other options. We have a number of home games coming up and if we don’t perform over the next month Brown will be under threat.

What concerns me most is our biggest problem area in defence has not improved for some time and the quality sides all use the same game plan to beat us ( run decoys at the half\ second rower and play at the back, score in the corner). What was concerning about today thou was some of our poor defensive reads came from our experienced heads like Lillyman and Hieghtening on Lewis.

Brown has an issue no amount of coaching can fix and that’s that the only two halfbacks in the club are injuried and no one else has the ability to play seven. Cogger is lost out their he does not know what to do with the ball once he gets it and looks to Watson for instructions plus his kicking game is non existent.

Wests did not grow to be the organisation like they are today on the back of blind faith so don’t expect them to now starting place that in Brown. If they do look elsewhere it will be to someone with a proven track record and I think that will be Michael Maguire.
 
Quinny said:
I am a big Brown fan I think he has done a lot for this club and have defended him on here numerous times before but after the last month I think you would be naive to not think Wests are looking at other options. We have a number of home games coming up and if we don’t perform over the next month Brown will be under threat.

What concerns me most is our biggest problem area in defence has not improved for some time and the quality sides all use the same game plan to beat us ( run decoys at the half\ second rower and play at the back, score in the corner). What was concerning about today thou was some of our poor defensive reads came from our experienced heads like Lillyman and Hieghtening on Lewis.

Brown has an issue no amount of coaching can fix and that’s that the only two halfbacks in the club are injuried and no one else has the ability to play seven. Cogger is lost out their he does not know what to do with the ball once he gets it and looks to Watson for instructions plus his kicking game is non existent.

Wests did not grow to be the organisation like they are today on the back of blind faith so don’t expect them to now starting place that in Brown. If they do look elsewhere it will be to someone with a proven track record and I think that will be Michael Maguire.
Click to expand...

I’m not sold on Brown yet. Just think that the main problem is the standard of players not the coaching.

Better to fix that first then if things don’t get better then change the coach.

Sione can’t blame his defence on Brown.
 
Brown certainly deserves until the end of the season. We can reassess then. If a better coach is available we should definitely consider it.
 
You must log in or register to reply here.
Back
Top