member 2299
Danny 'Bedsy' Buderus
Ethan you got it wrong.
There's contributing factors to every accident in this case that's 1 of them and I remember at the time everyone saying he shouldn't have ducked his head he was trying to roll out of the tackle but now its taboo to even say that ....but as I said before if Mclean doesn't lift nothing happens ...With that first sentence yes you are.
There's contributing factors to every accident in this case that's 1 of them and I remember at the time everyone saying he shouldn't have ducked his head he was trying to roll out of the tackle but now its taboo to even say that ....but as I said before if Mclean doesn't lift nothing happens ...
Read and learn Left Foot!
It's only a contributing factor under the law if Alex made a deliberate and conscious decision to do it. If it could be proved that Alex was trying to fall on his head to milk a penalty - that would be a contributing factor. What his instincts told him to do in a split second is not a contributing factor. It is not something he could control in any way, so not his fault.Ethan is right!
There are contributing factors to all injuries, car accidents or whatever.
It's unpopular to say, but alex ducking his head was without doubt a contributing factor to his injury. If he doesn't duck his head for my books, he would not have suffered as severe an injury.
Take a car accident as a good example. Speed may be a factor in an accident, not the cause, but a factor. More damage can happen in the accident due to the speed, but that does not mean the person speeding was at fault. The person may not have even been speading, 60km/h vs 40km/h, that extra 20 increases the damage in an accident and is a factor.
Thats not saying he is to blame for what happened. Lifting in the tackle was to blame as if that didn't happen, there would be no injury at all.
Do you really think so R_A?
I reckon when he goes, he goes and Alex knows that and looking ahead to a new challenge.
He would need to be able to run on and off the field to be a trainer, I don't think anyone believes this to be possible.I don't expect him to either, but who knows, with new experiences, and knowledge he may come back to give back and help out again. He's doing a degree (not sure if he's finished) and might do another one at some point so there are opportunities for him rather then being pigeonholed into one thing.
What if by some crazy chance, he can walk again, to an extent, maybe being a trainer or something? Who knows.