Discussion in 'Newcastle Knights Discussion' started by goalpost, Oct 9, 2009.
i reckon people could put together a better team then we have atm
Knights will win in 2010
I dont get it
there is enormous amount of newcastle players running around at other clubs, that were never given a real chance at newcastle
dane tilse, the knights should be disgraced at the way they treated him
michael ennis, fair enough he was behind buderus - also he should be in the aus team ahead of farah
and thats just of the top of me head
From that list there's no one other than maybe Tupou I'd want back. We treated Tilse fine imo, he sexually assaulted a women after entering her room without permission, would you prefer we kept him?
yes i would of preferred it if we kept him
im not saying what he did was right, im saying that it wasnt just him involved
he was used as a scape goat
and as far as i know he was never charged with anything...
and how could u not want ennis over de gois
walsh or finsh over rogers and dureau
birdy the bloke is freak
♥ Terrence Seu Seu ♥
Because i quite simply dont want him over De Gois.
De Gois = Gun.
To be honest, there's no great stars on the list I'd want back.
Finch and Kimmorley were never going to stay with Johns here, there's nobody to blame for that. Mason, Bird and Tilse are all trouble we are better off without. Mason at his peak would have been good of course, but that's long gone now.
Tighe wouldn't get a starting spot ahead of MacDougall and Sau.
Really the only three in that list I'd want back would be Ennis, Burt and Tupou. Ennis we should never have let go without more of a fight, but he wanted to play hooker and didn't see any future with Buderus there. He was making a great fist of playing lock in 2004, though ... why didn't we try harder to convince him he had a first grade spot there?
That was Hagan for you though, made some baffling decisions. I'm more than happy with De Gois in the side now, though, he is a great player.
ennis is no lock
how can u say tilse is trouble
he made one silly mistake and he payed the price, as other players should of aswell
as for bird and mason they have both done stupid crap... but most footy players do
most ppl do
also de gois is obviously not a team player after his little stunt in the finals this yr
Dude, I wouldn't exactly call sexual assault a silly mistake.
I'm glad he's gone.
Tupou is a dud, I'm glad he is not here.
I'd have Woolnough back.
How the hell was that a stunt? So you are blaming it all on him? The doctors gave him ok, and anyone would've taken it. How would he know that it was going to get injured first minute?
Do you also blame Taia for his stunt then? He let in two tries because of his shoulder.
Would take Carmont back in a heartbeat also.
Truer words were never spoken he is a pathetic excuse for a footballer the fact Cronulla have wasted 400k a year on him is a joke.
Looking at that list you can tell we've kept the right players.
So you wouldn/t want to play in the finals even if the docs said that you were ok?
Clint Newton & Kirk Reynoldson... bring them back. We need them.
So they always remind us.
We should start a bring back Reyno campaign!
Does Tahu count?
Separate names with a comma.