Legit question, he had us in 6th when it was revealed the Roosters had signed him after WE refused to extend him, had a squad that was insanely passionate and trying their guts out every week. - Then our playing group basically threw match's until he was gone. We were living within in our means and developing a very nice balanced squad and were no doubt on the improve. As a club to me that's been the golden time since Joey and if we had of kept him we were every chance of developing into a premiership winning squad with our odds and ends team. Since than Stone came in and let things slide by being a soft c--k, Bennett came and poured petrol on the place and burned us to the ground, Stone came back and threw more logs on the fire, and it's only after 3 more years of Brown we are possibly looking like turning a corner and there is no guarantee's his method will yield success. Worst decision we made and I'll get flamed for it was not extending Smith, he from memory asked for an extension which we dumbly refused, I think at the time probably myself and others at the time weren't against the decision but yeah....... Definitely a bad one IMO.