I haven't taken anything personally or been offended, not sure why you think that and I am not a family friend or family member. Also how have I been misleading or left anything open to interpretation?
I'm just correctly pointing out that your opinion is not shared by selectors with more experience and much better credentials than yourself and that you were incorrect in your claim that Wilkinson has never been previously picked in a representative squad.
You are also incorrect in your claim that "numerous spots were left open for country kids", there were only two positions, not numerous positions in the NSW Pathways squad.
Black didn't make the NSW Pathways squad a year young while eligible the same year Wilkinson did make the team, yet he also didn't make the team last year when he was the "right" age. It would be reasonable to suggest at least some of the selectors over these two seasons were the same. From the selection and non selection it would also be reasonable to suggest the selectors opinion was that Wilkinson was a better option and deserved a spot in the extended squad while Black didn't.
You asked "If he is that good why isn't he playing open nsw Chs, Aus School boys, Origin, or any other rep team.?" suggesting that Wilkinson is a lesser player because he did not make any of these sides. However when I again correctly pointed out the fact Black didn't make any of these sides either (as well as not making Pathways) rather than admitting that perhaps Black too is a lesser player your reply was that these teams are only "nice teams to make to put on your resume". Some people would suggest this is misleading and open to the interpretation that you are a hypocrite.
We are currently coming into Round 8 of the SG Ball competition. So far Wilkinson has been named to start five times and been named on the bench once and eighteenth man once. Black has been named to start three times and named on the bench twice. This would suggest that the opinion of the Knights coaches and selectors differs to yours and at this stage Wilkinson is a better player and option. Whether this be because of the age difference, maturity, size, skill, team dynamics or a combination of all.